Here now if you want to talk
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Twin Trap Mafia Town win
- Thread starter Metal Sonic
- Start date
Tell me your thoughts about the game and the people in the game
Just switched to pc.
Currect reads is
clarinet
fenrir
Duskfall
Texas
Jordan
sultan
bd
smogon account
I personally can't see clarinet flipping scum with posts like
That's a reads list, I want your specific thoughts
My thoughts are that I shouldn't be lynched
Lynching lurkers is fair but lurkers are what you typically lynch when you don't have a lynch plan. Usually isn't the case day 1 (though idk on smogon).
Duskfall trying to clear Clarinet didn't sit that well with me though his more recent posts have made me think he's town.
pocket successful
Get well soon!
the toni lynch gives me some apprehension because jordan is the only one opposed to it, I think.
In a 2 wolf game I don't think day 1 bussing is the pro strat you need to win, so I doubt toni is a wolf unless their partner is jordan
whereas I believe fenrir actually slipped a scummy mindset and is lynchable because of it
compare that to the reasoning for toni lynch
-NAI stuff
I would be more willing to lynch toni if they actually had any negative content but I haven't really seen anything lynchable from the slot
In a 2 wolf game I don't think day 1 bussing is the pro strat you need to win, so I doubt toni is a wolf unless their partner is jordan
whereas I believe fenrir actually slipped a scummy mindset and is lynchable because of it
compare that to the reasoning for toni lynch
-NAI stuff
I would be more willing to lynch toni if they actually had any negative content but I haven't really seen anything lynchable from the slot
out of four people who've commented on it?
Hello everyone I will not be on at deadline for obvious reasons if you are aware of my timezone. I would greatly appreciate if we could shift the lynch to Jordan however I understand if we must lynch Toni at this point.
Wait are you scumreading Jordan or not, you mention them in a possible scum team but I don't see a real stance?
I'm not, but if toni was a wolf I concluded that jordan would be the partner
somewhat hastily according to texas
i'm here, waiting for the post dinner food coma to pass
Sultan of Skook will be replaced.
Lynch xnadrojx
smogon account
- 85 is a towny post, also very wrong (its not a double standard if the circumstance is different). the premise of this post leads to a very natural conviction in his follow on, the persecution of a town with a scent.
clarinet
- there's a certain level of sophistication that goes into making a post like 29 if you're scum it's pretty difficult to try to derpclear yourself as scum trying to look like town without faiing at either the clear or the alignment read, this one is tonally pure imo.
jordan
-70 is pingy, targeting duskfall is barely of note but it almost looks like he's looking for a deliberate way to stay under the radar from me. 95 is pingy, shading dusk hard for soft reasons and not committing to the push verbally or with a vote. 107 is verrrry pingy and not for the reaso you'd think. 126 is more of the same as 95
bluedoom
- still really don't like 41+47, pushing for a ride or die wagon and then backtracking immediately as random is o_o but as i type this out that backtrack is probably more likely to be town than not, scum more likely to double down
fenrir
- 77 looks very towny to me, lots of committal positions, not specifically trying to wagon build, the read on smogon account shows a good though process even if the post in question was just bravado
toni
- should probably die because they dont post readable content
sultan
-low key angle shooting as town, the sub out and reasoning could happen as scum but you're a lot more likely to try and wait until a night cycle at least. if you're in that head space and facing the prospect of reading the game you're giving up as town a lot more so this slot is pseudo-IC for me. 58 is also pretty pure.
duskfall
- town, tone read from page 5 and 128
- 85 is a towny post, also very wrong (its not a double standard if the circumstance is different). the premise of this post leads to a very natural conviction in his follow on, the persecution of a town with a scent.
clarinet
- there's a certain level of sophistication that goes into making a post like 29 if you're scum it's pretty difficult to try to derpclear yourself as scum trying to look like town without faiing at either the clear or the alignment read, this one is tonally pure imo.
jordan
-70 is pingy, targeting duskfall is barely of note but it almost looks like he's looking for a deliberate way to stay under the radar from me. 95 is pingy, shading dusk hard for soft reasons and not committing to the push verbally or with a vote. 107 is verrrry pingy and not for the reaso you'd think. 126 is more of the same as 95
bluedoom
- still really don't like 41+47, pushing for a ride or die wagon and then backtracking immediately as random is o_o but as i type this out that backtrack is probably more likely to be town than not, scum more likely to double down
fenrir
- 77 looks very towny to me, lots of committal positions, not specifically trying to wagon build, the read on smogon account shows a good though process even if the post in question was just bravado
toni
- should probably die because they dont post readable content
sultan
-low key angle shooting as town, the sub out and reasoning could happen as scum but you're a lot more likely to try and wait until a night cycle at least. if you're in that head space and facing the prospect of reading the game you're giving up as town a lot more so this slot is pseudo-IC for me. 58 is also pretty pure.
duskfall
- town, tone read from page 5 and 128
Lynch these people
Jordan
Then lynch these people
toni
bluedoom
Don't lynch these people
clarinet
smogon account
fenrir
duskfall
sultan
texas
in reverse order of town-scum
Jordan
Then lynch these people
toni
bluedoom
Don't lynch these people
clarinet
smogon account
fenrir
duskfall
sultan
texas
in reverse order of town-scum
toni has two votes (dusk, bluedoom) and plurality, jordan needs three to be roped
everyone watching needs to choose between jordan and toni, minimize wagon splitting
everyone watching needs to choose between jordan and toni, minimize wagon splitting
Clarinet smogon account bluedoom tonithetourguide XnadrojX Fenrir Aesir Duskfall98
deadline in 90 minutes, see post above
deadline in 90 minutes, see post above
I would choose Jordan out of the two because the flip gives us interactions and leads for day 1
but with all due respect unless it comes down to it I'm keeping my vote on who i think is a wolf
but with all due respect unless it comes down to it I'm keeping my vote on who i think is a wolf
vanity wagons are actively harmful to town
unless you're planning on making a case to convince people to vote fenrir today you can circle back and vote him tomorrow, today, right now, you need to be placing your vote on either the main or counter wagon because that will be directly beneficial in solving later in the game