Eli Manning just came off a fantastic comeback season. The dude also had one of the greatest seasons ever by a qb and carried one of the crapiest teams ever to a super bowl win in 11. That teams highlights include being outscored by their opponents in the regular season, 27th ranked defense, worst rushing offense and worst ol at pass protection. He carried that team with miracle after miracle. Including an insane 15 4th quater passing Tds and more than half of the regular season wins on miracle game winning drives. That season alone was good enough to get him into the HoF. Also his game against the 49ers in the NFC championship game was the best performance I've ever seen by a quarterback.