Reasonable mostly applies to the evolution that looks like it isn't going to happen. It has to be something suggested by the movepool / concept. For example, I find it weird to give a Fighting type to a Pokemon without Fighting moves.My only advice would be that it is impossible to really choose what is "reasonable."
I mean, theoretically there could be a Fire/Water pokemon or a Fire/Ice Pokemon. They aren't quite realistic but might be pulled off with some innovative design.
My recommendation would be to start with a more exotic type like Fire, Ghost, Dark, Steel, or Dragon, and move from there. Every single type is essentially reasonable with something like Water or Flying.
In fact, I almost think it would be better to start with a Role poll (or even something broader like a concept discussion) before going into type.
I've already counted twelve of them. And there are like three votes on this page. A poll would defeat the purpose of this.Ok what is this thread accomplishing right now, unless you still plan on tabulating all the votes throughout 13 pages yourself
imo make a new thread with a poll, and maybe arguments for and against each option in the OP. i feel like this thread is just getting bogged down and too long to read for people starting to post in it
I really hope they don't evolve Skarmory/Heracross/Hippowdon.I changed my mind to new pokemon. What's the point of making new evolutions? Face it, sooner or later nintendo is gonna evolve every non legendary that doesn't already have 3 stages. So eventually all the evos we create will be useless once the real ones come out.
No nintendo won't. Not everything needs an evolution.Just like wha MwL said, what if skarm got an evo, it would be uber. Unless they mad it steel/bug hehe lol. After 10 years they decided to evolve tangela and magmar/electibuzz. We would have to wait centeries to evolve all of them.I changed my mind to new pokemon. What's the point of making new evolutions? Face it, sooner or later nintendo is gonna evolve every non legendary that doesn't already have 3 stages. So eventually all the evos we create will be useless once the real ones come out.
All 3 were together in the Kanto dex, with the same typings as the legendary birds, and they all got baby forms in the second generation.Not to bash the whole, "JYNX NEEDS EVO BADLY OMG"
I don't see her compared to Electabuzz and Magmar, really.
She's more of Mr. Mime's counterpart.
Jynx is a girl Psychic Pokemon, and Mr. Mime was supposedly a male Psychic Pokemon in R/B/Y?All 3 were together in the Kanto dex, with the same typings as the legendary birds, and they all got baby forms in the second generation.
...Mr. Mime? I don't really see the connection...
Yeah counterparts always get evos at the same time. Like Dusclops and Bane-OWAIT.If Electabuzz, Magmar, and Jynx were together, she would've gotten an evolution.
That or he, like me, just wants all the New Poke opinions to count...