1. Some of Gen 8 is a little underwhelming to me (Cinderace, Indeedee)
2. Some things about the story are... infamous.
3. Say what you want about Pokemon graphics, but much of Galar is pretty. Nice music too.
4. Mega Evolution is still my favourite "super mechanic," but Dynamax was a lot better than I expected. (...) The transformation was boring, but the mechanic was fun. It largely accomplished my old hope for Mega Evolution, in that it made a wide variety of Pokemon at least usable for something, even if not really competitively viable. And obviously the more boring generalized transformation helped them to achieve that. I'm a little pessimistic about Terestal, but if Dynamax was any example, it should be fine.
5. Max Raid Battles are kind of silly, but the temporary events that they put into the dens were great for collecting interesting Pokemon. I have a whole consistent route now for riding my bike around the Wild Area and the DLC areas. Between VGC and those raid events, they really did have me going back and playing SwSh all throughout the gen. On that note, keeping SwSh as the main traditional/battling games of Gen 8 freed them to be innovative with Legends: Arceus, while events kept SwSh alive. It seems like a good model for the future.
1. I don't mind Cinderace, I know people have problem with the Pokemon who look like they're wearing clothing, but at the same time I'm also looking at an anthropomorphic rabbit with fiery hair; I can overlook the shorts (it's not like Lucario wearing shorts seem to bother many). But I actually like Indeedee's design. Yes, in shape it is similar to Audino, but I feel the color scheme and horns are enough to separate it (also they're both "Assistant" Pokemon, the anime having them serve alongside Nurse Joy in Galar, so they're going to have some things similar). Hm, not sure what Pokemon Paldean Nurse Joys will have, especially since they're not really in a building but an open kiosk. Maybe Dolliv/Arboliva? Though I would be surprised if Officer Jenny aren't given Cyclizar with harnesses that have a police siren.
2. Galar has the recipe for a great dish, but to get it out "in time" they took shortcuts. And instead of a great dish they wound up with a meal that leaves much to be desired. The individual ingredients are good, but they just don't mix together in a satisfying way.
3. I think Pokemon's main problem is that it's trying to use somewhat realistic graphics when they should just go full out stylistic. Think about it, no Pokemon uses realistic textures, yet they're living in an environment which does which creates a visual dichotomy. What they need to do is make simple textures based off Pokemon supposedly made of or mimicking said textures and use those for the trees, rocks, ground, cliffsides, etc..
4. Terastal to be honest is meh. I got more fun in defeating my opponents without using Terastal just because they make a big show out of it. Then again, it didn't help ALL the NPCs which Terastallize did so with the same Type of their active Pokemon, which meant you likely had out a Pokemon which was Super Effective or at least Resistant to their Type, which meant despite Terastallizing they probably didn't use any Move which would benefit from the Terastal as they would also go with the backup neutral coverage. GF, what were you THINKING would happen? The only clever one was Iono because Electric is only weak to Ground and she used a Pokemon with Levitate!
Honestly if any game showed how to do a super mechanic I'd argue it be Pokken. When a Pokemon did a Synergy Burst, if they had a Mega Evo they would Mega Evolve, but if they didn't they still got a special effect of some kind added to them to show they were still powered-up. They didn't need to grow big, most of the time they either got a power aura or parts of them began glowing. Heck, if even that is too much, just give them a batch of stat increases and maybe Ability change so they have a similar power of a Mega without being one (with the only advantage a Mega getting is that their stats won't decrease from anything which clear stat changes like Haze).
5. Some bad news here. I feel they botched Terastal Raids. In trying to make them "quicker" they just make them feel chaotic without feeling anymore faster as now the Raid Pokemon had done 3 other Moves you didn't see some of which could have been a buffing Move. Also, while the higher level Dynamax Raids still felt possible even if you didn't have a Dynamax Pokemon of your own, higher level Terastal are just the WORST! Because of the Type change, in order to do Super Effective damage it may put you in a disadvantage against their normal STAB moves (also, unless they're normally the same Type as the Tera Type, they may not have a Move of the Tera Type). This is especially bad because when they put up their shield not only do you need the power boost from Terastal but if its not Super Effective you might as well just be throwing foam balls at it. This is because, unlike Dynamax where the shielded Pokemon's shield took a certain number of hits to break, Tera Pokemon still use their HP but now just have a major defensive boost. Also, when you broke a Dynamax Pokemon's shield their defensive stats lowered, but Tera Pokemon don't look to have any negative side effects for breaking their shield aside losing the added defensive boost. Also the Tera Timer is EASILY worst than the Dynamax 4 Knockouts/10 Turns. Hey, GF, unless you were hoping players gaming the 7 Star Event Raids by coming up with niche strategies, you FAILED to make a Raid system better than Dynamax.
Steam Eruption no longer comes from both of Volcanion's cannons.
Wicked Blow was changed into a One Inch Punch move.
So they did more work to make the Signature Moves feel less special then had they recycled the old animations.
After you rematch Iono in the postgame, she says something to the effect of "I'm trending like the Internet is mad at me!"
Considering this game's unfair user review-bombed reception (SV are the lowest user-rated games in the series which is ridiculous), I have a feeling this was snuck in by a genre savvy staff member at the last minute. It's the biggest "DANG, BOYEEEEEEE" moment I've ever seen in a game. Whether it was oddly predicting the backlash to SV or simply poking fun at SWSH's Dexit reception, I find the line absolutely hysterical that I immediately paused the game and breathlessly got my computer to post about it. 10/10 satire.
Certainty genre savvy, but I don't think in that way. If anything it more feels like a commentary on Cancel Culture, especially when the target is an egotist. Cancel culture ("the internet is mad") targets the egotist, they start trending, and that just makes the egotist happy as that means people are thinking about them and possibly listening to what they're saying. Yeah, sure, Iono is losing, but because she's battling the new Champion, its getting her thousands of views so why should she care? Which isn't a good attitude for a Gym Leader to take, which is why when Geeta asked me who was the "Easiest" Gym Leader I said Iono cause I don't think she's Gym Leader quality (also she had a chance to knock out my Garganacl who was sweeping her entire team when up against her Tera Mismagius, she just needed to do Charge Beam again but for some reason did Shadow Ball. Even if the game was pretending not to know my Garganacl had Purifying Salt until she used a Ghost-type move on me, Charge Beam would have knocked out no matter what so what's the logic here game?).
And yes, I gave Larry a glowing report, cause the man deserves it.
During the champion assessment, you're asked who the Gym leader you struggled the most is... and you get to face him/her again as E4.
By now you know that isn't true... BUT that's definitely something someone should consider doing in the future. Pokemon, Temtem, whoever, just have a way for the game to track which boss you had the hardest time with and then have them face you again in the final gauntlet, lol!
Thank god we're getting actually entertaining glitches as opposed to say softlocks and frozen internal clocks.
Look, she saw a hot guy (or gal, I don't judge), she just can't help herself.
OH, it was sideways!
I thought it was odd they didn't try to make the bases form the constellation.
But, wait... no, that's still not right. Infact, if we go by the base names, it's impossible to make the constellation. According to that image, Giacomo is Segin (correct), Mela is Ruchbah, Atticus is Navi (correct), Eri is Schedar, and Ortega is Caph. And flipping it doesn't work as, while Mela would be right, Segin would then be wrong (not to mention Eri and Ortega). GF, why do that? Did they take the names/traits of the star into consideration when assigning names? Well, if so, why didn't you then place the Star Bases in the proper places and adjusted the difficulty using that? Eri could have still been the toughest and last one you were supposed to battle, though she's the only member I can see which you'd want to be in a specific place as she's supposed to be the "muscle" of the group (or appear to be). And it's not like the bases HAD to be where they were place, they're just a batch of tents grouped together.
Japanese name is "astirngent" which
Astringency, the
dry, puckering or numbing
mouthfeel caused by the
tannins[2][3] in unripe fruits, lets the fruit mature by deterring eating. Ripe fruits and fruit parts including
blackthorn (sloe berries),
Aronia chokeberry,
chokecherry,
bird cherry,
rhubarb,
quince and
persimmon fruits (especially those which are unripe),
banana skins (or unripe bananas),
cashew fruits and acorns are astringent.
[4] Citrus fruits, like lemons, are somewhat astringent. Tannins, being a kind of
polyphenol, bind salivary
proteins and make them precipitate and
aggregate,
[5][6][7] producing a rough,
"sandpapery", or dry sensation in the mouth. The tannins in some
teas,
coffee, and red grape
wines like
Cabernet Sauvignon and
Merlot produce mild astringency.
Out of curiosity, does anyone know what the Salty Herba Mystica is called in Japan?
It does have those weird tube things.
It also learns Pin Missile, so maybe it shoots spikes out of them.
Not Pin Missile, but Pokemon Adventures showed Janine's Forretress using Spikes just like that:
The anime also had Brock's Forretress use Spikes but it was more ambiguous as they had Forretress also spinning around when launching the spikes (though the tubes were out, which is notable as whenever Forretress attacked while spinning it recalled the tubes so it could fully close its shell).
Area Zero is perfect. Genuinely feels like a modern day Cerulean Cave, except even more ominous due to having multiple high level encounters in the overworld, ominous music, and being far away from civilization. The presence of multiple final evolutions of 3 stage lines like Corviknight and Raichu really helps sell that the Pokemon there are on another level and that you shouldn't be there.
Corviknight evolves at Level 38 and Raichu via a Thunder Stone, not really red flags.
NOW the Volcarona on the other hand, well, that gets the feeling across we've entered into end game territory.
My only gripe is that they don't seem to correspond to the flavors of the Herba Mystica.
I wouldn't fault Arven on that. If anything, since he based his other 5 Pokemon on the flavors, that means he only had those 5 to work with and so just chose the best one for the job. Sometimes he came in with an advantage, sometimes he just came in neutral.
In general that the ancients are bigger and the futuristic ones smaller is nice touch into detail. Still would have prefered not every future paradox Pokemon to be robotic or have Iron in the name. Cyber Bird or Delibot would be nice for a name for Iron Bundle. Or has crossbreeding Pokemon never lead to a new species in the future?
Also the dex entry in Scarlet for Future Hydreigon is... questionable...
But some hidden lore in the games hint conflicting information about the legendary beasts and what they used to be before what we saw them as after Ho-Oh saved them. Maybe they weren't Eeveelutions like we used to think which would line up perfectly. Or Ho-oh's power granted them the power of the ancient past as it can learn Ancient Power... But that is headcanon.
What worries me more is, if ancient Pokemon were that strong, why are fossil Pokemon that weak? I would think the past far back must have been even harsher.
We had a discussion about this in the Mystery/Conspiracy thread:
Are we absolutely sure these Pokemon are from the past & future?
To be fair on the last point the "Billion Years" thing for Scream Tail sounds more like tabloid/magazine clickbait hyperbole, or as noted rumors that probably were started by speculators and influencers that don't know biology or evolution, even if they still agree on it being an ancient Puff
That's because it is from a tabloid/paranormal magazine, the Occulture.
Especially since, if the Pokemon World formed like the real world, a billion years ago the Earth was "stuck" in a 1 billion time period famously called the
Boring Billion. Now scientists are fighting back against that term as more evidence shows there were changes going on during this time, but the gist of it was that on a grander scale for about a billion years nothing really changed on Earth which included life. It existed, its believed some was multicell, but because how stagnant things were life wasn't able to advance much further until enough pressure finally built up to force the plates and landmasses to move thus causing massive changes in the environment.
In other words, no, Scream Tail likely is not from a Billon Years ago. Even if we were to exaggerate a billion year old Pokemon's size (that was a Legendary god), I imagine it would more look like a Grimer or Ditto, just a pile of slime. Honestly, that "billion year" thing alone makes me wonder if originally they were planning on using Grimer or Ditto cause why would you even think of that for Jigglypuff? Like, with it giving it long hair, I would think the clickbait title for Wild Scream would be writing how it was like Tarzan, swinging from tree to tree in the ancient past letting out loud screams.
Speaking of Hyper Beam, its animation in
Sword and Shield goes super hard.
And the opponent only faints.
Assuming sea water in Pokemon follows Physics like ours, this would require more energy than exists in the known universe to produce, or at the very least more than could exist on Earth without essentially disintegrating it. All this to say the funny Anglerfish has a bright light.
If we use my P
okeMatter theory, the light particles could be made from PokeMatter thus have no mass to be stopped by the seawater thus the "light" can reach the surface from miles underneath the water.
When something in Pokemon sounds impossible, just apply PokeMatter. It's like magic, but with Pokemon-flavored pseudo science!
I also appreciate choice but I kind of can't be mad since they went to such ridiculous lengths to ensure that you accept it. They could have just... left it there able to be collected later at a time that suits you like most gift Pokemon. But no.
Or be like "Hey, this jet bird wants to join your party, choose which Pokemon you want to be sent back to the PC so we have a reason to give you the ability to Soar".
I like how, of all things, Headbutting trees actually sort of came back as a mechanic.
Yesterday spent some time headbutting trees looking for a Pineco to fill my dex. I have to wonder what Miraidon was thinking the entire time I kept boosting it over and over again into the same batch of trees...