I'm not lying. I'm not sure what you want me to say. Post #47Yeah, i don't like the fact you're lying so much. both of your reasons could be resolved by simply being honest.
I played dumb because Twilight Princess NOC was almost 1 year ago, and only 3 players in this game participated in that game (cowbell being host, celever was playing at somepoint, and lightwolf was also there). What didn't help was the DDOS attack that was going on at the time of the game, preventing the game from continuing. There was hardly a random voting stage in TP NOC, rather bandwagoning and lynch-voting the experienced players, like Lightwolf and Aura Guardian. If you notice in TP NOC, my first and second post I was running an antisocial witch hunt, and only when I centered my aim on one person did I lynch vote. The previous game I played in, PMD, there was not a random voting stage. Everyone just took a dump on talkinglion day 1. I am simply not accustomed to the random voting stage, because it hasn't happened in a game I was in. The most recent game I was in was heartless mafia by yeti. This game didn't have lynch votes, so it doesn't count for this. I honestly didn't understand the random lynching because I didn't study it up in different games or mafiascum, and I played dumb to..
A) Get someone to tell me why people were random voting so I didn't have to try to find out myself,
B) Make people think that I am a noob, making them slightly disregard my erratic posting habits,
I like Paperblade's answer too: mafia is hard
What I'm saying is that my I am not very careful when I post, so I do dumb things like accusing someone of not posting 5 minutes after they post.
If I had a nickel for every time I've resorted to saying this as mafia, I could buy Smogon. Obbmud's still acting sketchy as shit. My vote remains.I'm not sure what you want me to say.
I think obbmud's explanation as to why he didn't really get rvs was pretty ok, and it's correct, as far as I can judge. You shouldn't make people think you're a noob by playing dumb, though, you should just make the best posts you can and take pride in the fact that mafia want you dead because you're the best scumhunter in the game (or at least you should aspire to be :))I find it hard to believe that someone who played mafia could be unfamiliar with random voting. Even if you did, you could have take a more straight-forward approach to it. All thing considered, that first post made me feel uncomfortable.
What makes you think this?it feels too much like he is just nervous and doesn't want to be witch hunted
Interesting you point out that DLL's vote and supporting B_T, when B_T's vote on DLL was no different. Both votes tried to pass off a pointless detail as a valid lynch target, and unlike DLL, B_T has admitted to his vote being serious. I mean look at DLL's post, it's as serious as me voting you Celever. I do not mind pressuring him into being active since extension day is upon us, but at least be reasonable in you accusations. Also aren't you falling into the exact same situation, second vote on what is 100% going to be the next bandwagon based, that sure sounds like what DLL did on the first page and what you called scumtell just now. You are contradicting yourself enough to honestly warrant a vote from me, but I still wish to pressure Obbmud for at least another post. That doesn't stop you from answering my concerns I hope!In the meantime, however, I will Lynch Da Letter El because not only is he inactive like B_T said, he also jumped the gun with Ullar. While this is fairly minor and was obviously a troll post, it still can be noted that he really created a freshly made wagon which I usually consider a scumtell. And then he kind of died and hasn't posted since.
Interesting you point out that DLL's vote and supporting B_T, when B_T's vote on DLL was no different. Both votes tried to pass off a pointless detail as a valid lynch target, and unlike DLL, B_T has admitted to his vote being serious. I mean look at DLL's post, it's as serious as me voting you Celever. I do not mind pressuring him into being active since extension day is upon us, but at least be reasonable in you accusations. Also aren't you falling into the exact same situation, second vote on what is 100% going to be the next bandwagon based, that sure sounds like what DLL did on the first page and what you called scumtell just now. You are contradicting yourself enough to honestly warrant a vote from me, but I still wish to pressure Obbmud for at least another post. That doesn't stop you from answering my concerns I hope!
I tried to make it apparent in my post that I'm not seriously considering DLL (which sounds better imo) for a lynch, but because of the circumstances of a rather average day 1 I decided to go with the only semi-kinda-half-lead we had, and it turns out that B_T had also voted for him. Honestly I didn't make a connection between what I was doing and what DLL did because I did this lynch semi-seriously, but not really. I don't know, but I feel like you're looking into this a little bit too much for now. Honestly my entire logic for voting anyone was because a few posts above B_T was talking about how unvoting and not revoting is a scum tell now or something. Seriously, I wasn't trying to advocate a lynch or anything, I was just trying to stay alive as any villager would.Celever 1 Paragraph Above said:I'm not getting huge vibes from anyone else
Why are you getting so defensive? You are very cagey and defensive just because you are trying to look like you are participating and calling out others that are not doing so. Instead of explaining how Obbmud's logic wasn't bad, you just simply drop it instead of digging deeper. Rather than going "I like B_T; what he said, lynch DLL", you went on a very detailed explanation as to why B_T was correct, one totally unneeded/unwarranted by the circumstances. Next, the case boils down to "this person jokevoted and then disappeared for 36 hours"; seeing someone show up on "Who's Online" and not posting in the thread is not generally considered grounds for a lynch in my opinion. That's a pretty weak case. Good enough for D1, I guess, but not one you spend an entire paragraph *of someone else's words* on. Finally, B_T's vote on DLL was timed and scoped specifically for pressure. While it's developed into a serious vote, that's not why it was originally made, so for you to pass it off as a serious vote is dumb. You voted DLL for what? You borrowed what you thought was B_T "serious" lynch to do so instead of coming up with your own.Jesus Christ guys this is an extremely fast bandwagon. Like some others have said, Obbmud's logic isn't actually that bad. I mean, Cancerous when he said that "if you have played mafia before you should now about the RVS" -- actually, I was playing in the Twilight Princess mafia which was also Obbmud's first game and there was no RVS in it. People just ganged up on LightWolf and tas iirc. But anyway, as that was also my first game, in the next NOC I played (Mario Kart, I believe?), what you are doing to Obbmud was very similar to what happened to me in that game. I.E, I had no clue what the RVS was thanks to there not being one in the beginner game, and then people thought I was acting dumb and playing up without checking and I got under fire. Thankfully I survived the onslaught of Spiffy and co. (Spiffy sux btw) but it was actually the mafias who were pressuring me the hardest. Because, imo, there are quite a few connections between what happened to me when I was village in Mario kart and what is happening now with Obbmud, I'm going to Unlynch Obbmud (I didn't think I had him voted, but I do in the vote count. Whatever :p) for now.
I'm not getting huge vibes from anyone else, but Cancerous aimlessly bandwagoned on both Ullar and Obbmud, and he was spouting information without backing it up. I would lynch Cancerous right now, but he is the Town Innocent Child. Cancerous, as the Inno Child you must check your info. You are essential to the village so please put lots of thought into your posts and check over things. A little bit later on people might start relying on you (personally I don't like becoming entirely reliant on anyone, but still) so you honestly have lots of bargaining power. Please use it wisely.
In the meantime, however, I will Lynch Da Letter El because not only is he inactive like B_T said, he also jumped the gun with Ullar. While this is fairly minor and was obviously a troll post, it still can be noted that he really created a freshly made wagon which I usually consider a scumtell. And then he kind of died and hasn't posted since.
This is a excuse to jump on the bandwagon against me. You have no question of your own. You have no agreement with other people's points. You don't even attempt to point out any confusion you see in my post. You just tell us that you are confused, and lynch. To me this seems like a band wagon. Are you ready to go to Oregon?
??? How do role PMs have anything to do with my lack of attentiveness, which i fully admit to?obbmud99 said:he claimed that he didn't know anything was going on, but he had smogon activity at 8:11 PM on Saturday, and I believe that role PMs were sent out between 2:35 PM to 3:15 PM.
your post was literally 2 lines long I don't think I need to point out a specific part of that.You don't even attempt to point out any confusion you see in my post.
Could you clarify what you meant when you said "i forgot to watch this thread so i thought nothing was going on :/"? I interpreted it as you saying that you forgot to click the watch thread button at the top of the screen before closing the window. If you had received the role PM around 8:11 PM on Saturday, you would have looked for the game, and see that it has started. There would have been 13 posts by players at this point, mostly voting RVS. There you would conclude that the game has started, so you could participate. I would understand if you thought the game was delayed after the role PM was sent out, waiting for an certain time for the game to start.??? How do role PMs have anything to do with my lack of attentiveness, which i fully admit to?your post was literally 2 lines long I don't think I need to point out a specific part of that.
My vote stays on you.
Why does this matter? If you're village, there should be no reason to attempt to conceal your posting habits from anyone, because you should have nothing to hide.
Unvote
Lynch Obbmud99
I'm gonna need some more explanation.
Unlynch Empoof
Lynch Obbmud99
His indecisiveness with his voting is obviously a sign of mafia!!!