-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Bard's College Mafia - Day Three
- Thread starter acidphoenix
- Start date
- Status
I'm still reading MS as uesless town as that's how he always posts; Fluff and assertions with 0 legitimate back-up. Although he is being significantly more rambly than usual so it may be scum MS, never played with him as scum iirc. If he does flip town (if lynch obv) I could see a AG/Leet scumteam being a possibility
itzviper482 is now asek
on the haruno inspecting texas thing I don't see why haruno as scum wants to implicate himself in such a way, if we decide to flip one to verify the check it seems very likely that haruno will be the one to go. The more probable scenario is they're both town, though claiming a clean check on someone who wasn't even remotely under fire before is a weird course of action ? idk I don't think I'd do it at least
don't think the FH/Texas mindmeld at deadline is staged either, more risk than reward here if FH flips mafia
twin's first post not being a vote on someone he suspected while spectating feels weird, i'm more used to him tunneling people hard
no idea whatsoever about AG need to iso
bloodyrain's posts are giving me a headache
i can't tell leet's town game from his scum game but he had a few posts that I didnt like at all, especially the ones where he quotes multiple people and goes "good post" or "haruno will be haruno"
i'm a bit lost in this game, need to find the motivation to do a reread
don't think the FH/Texas mindmeld at deadline is staged either, more risk than reward here if FH flips mafia
twin's first post not being a vote on someone he suspected while spectating feels weird, i'm more used to him tunneling people hard
no idea whatsoever about AG need to iso
bloodyrain's posts are giving me a headache
i can't tell leet's town game from his scum game but he had a few posts that I didnt like at all, especially the ones where he quotes multiple people and goes "good post" or "haruno will be haruno"
i'm a bit lost in this game, need to find the motivation to do a reread
somehow in the game where everyone agreed to push inactives on page 1 I have'nt been voted despite doing jack shit
vote hitmonleet
if everyone stops playing when I start it's gonna be a difficult game
also xnadrojx and hitmonleet voting MS feels too obvious of a connection for them to be scum together despite me finding both sketchy
if they were trying to build a counterwagon to save a teammate it could make sense but it just doesn't seem to be coherent here
if they were trying to build a counterwagon to save a teammate it could make sense but it just doesn't seem to be coherent here
I'm here but catching up in another game
I'm a little uncomfortable with the MS wagon, especially on how it built up as opposition to the toni slot
Still fine voting toni slot honestly since TTM said "what are flips" and then dipped out
I'm a little uncomfortable with the MS wagon, especially on how it built up as opposition to the toni slot
Still fine voting toni slot honestly since TTM said "what are flips" and then dipped out
Sounds like a more solid push than MS, who's reading hard null/very slight scumlean whereas I could see Twin/Toni being an idler-type mafia (and from experience Twin is usually much more active but he may just be catching up)
why would ms feel pressured if you say you're going to unvote anyway
town twin is much more active than this
^ yeah
I don't think a town replacement comes and dips out without providing any content
feels more like coasty scum to me
I don't think a town replacement comes and dips out without providing any content
feels more like coasty scum to me
Unvote
Upon consideration, I'm too uncertain of MS lynch.
Upon consideration, I'm too uncertain of MS lynch.
Is this really all that's been posted from this slot since Twin subbed in?
lynch twin
that said, super wifom, but on one hand you think a town person would post more...but on the other wouldn't you expect a mafia to post more to not be lynched?
Lynch Hitmonleet Reading through his posts he is extremely scummy to me because all his posts are just full of bullshit designed to look like he is actually providing useful thoughts(great example of this #545). Also find it quite suspicious that AG bandwagons leet on a vote towards MS even though the reasoning in the posts by leet are just blatant copying of reasoning from jordan/bloody. Also something of note is that ag never mentions leet at all besides for the vote on MS and leet has brought up AG as "suspicious" but has never laid out any reasoning why or has actually pushed AG.
Leet also ignores the posts by proph on 538-539 where he states that he is a bit wary of leet to respond to other posts about proph to then deflect into another subject in haruno which is just ringing more alarm bells from post 545
Leet's ignoring of posts that throw accusations of him being possible scum also lines up with his meta in his previous scum game in m12.
i feel the same way about leet every time. imo this time around i would place his play right in between popcorn and matrix noc. maybe closer towards the scum side. not a lot of voting a lot of quoting but just saying "this feels weird" or "i agree with you"
idk i can buy it. will hopefully contribute more tomorrow.
unvote vote leet
idk i can buy it. will hopefully contribute more tomorrow.
unvote vote leet
Asek
Banned deucer.
i subbed to you and you didnt sub back. you lack honor
this is a bad initial post
scum can influence inactive shoving to make sure that their members who post less dont get shoved on before town due to possesing the info of which inactives are town and which arent. not only this, but scum can actively pressure their inactives into posting so they have an easier time pushing onto lurkers they know who are town - who have nobody but host to try squeeze activity out of them
although it is desirable to have inatives gone before LYLO, the more effective method of dealing with 0 posters is to either wait for substitution or use investigative roles on the slots. lynching a 0 poster day1 is almost always a terrible idea - no matter what you hit the information from the flip is minimal - just stalling significat game progress
this is just baseless set up spec
former hope ping, this is some weird early flushing crap
- Status