Prophylaxis assuming my action went off successfully, you should have very strong reasoning to think I'm town based on what happened to you last night.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Bard's College Mafia - Day Three
- Thread starter acidphoenix
- Start date
- Status
DEAD TOWNIES
mxmts
KnightsofCydonia
TOWNIES
Prophylaxis
bluedoom
Texas Cloverleaf
PROB TOWN
Former Hope
Meowmixx
Jalmont
Haruno?
PROB TOWN ACCORDING TO TEXAS
XnadrojX
BLOODYRAIN1001
SELF RESOLVING
Champ1604
POE
Metal Sonic
MoodyCloud
Granny Pie
ItzViper482
Tonithetourgide
Hitmonleet
Earlio
Aura Guardian
?
mxmts
KnightsofCydonia
TOWNIES
Prophylaxis
bluedoom
Texas Cloverleaf
PROB TOWN
Former Hope
Meowmixx
Jalmont
Haruno?
PROB TOWN ACCORDING TO TEXAS
XnadrojX
BLOODYRAIN1001
SELF RESOLVING
Champ1604
POE
Metal Sonic
MoodyCloud
Granny Pie
ItzViper482
Tonithetourgide
Hitmonleet
Earlio
Aura Guardian
?
Yeah.
I assume you only want NOCs, so here:
Me as town
Me as Scum
Sorry that they're both pretty short, I have a history of early deaths.
It went off successfully. I still think you're town.
Thanks Hitmonleet for those games, once again I'll check them out when I get some free time.
Just want to see if that self consciousness is present in your town game.
Just want to see if that self consciousness is present in your town game.
I'll be back tonight.
I think there's like, one scum in my PROB TOWN section, but I feel fairly confident about bluedoom/Texas being town (Texas of course has a cop check on him, if we think Haruno is town).
I think most of the scumteam is in the POE and that's where I want to focus for Today.
I think there's like, one scum in my PROB TOWN section, but I feel fairly confident about bluedoom/Texas being town (Texas of course has a cop check on him, if we think Haruno is town).
I think most of the scumteam is in the POE and that's where I want to focus for Today.
Death might have interrupted his action.
Er, I missed more posts. That was re: poison granny
From my Haruno experience they either idle totally or say something that’s usually true (albeit sometimes stupidly obtuse) so I’m personally buying into Texas being town (that and the huge amounts of starting posts, while not explicitly town, don’t look like a mafia opening in the slightest)
Typing this out as I go through the thread.
Regarding Earlio's #375, I was confused for a bit too, this has probably been resolved already but it's just weird flavor. Or the role is really basatard and flips as the opposite alignment on death but since he was almost certainly the mafia kill that's impossible, so yeah, flavor text.
I like Texas's #383, it's a lot of logical enough reads, town read.
Jalmont seems to be getting really aggressive towards Texas later on Page 16, although I guess it's understandable since Texas parroted Proph on the "poor town play" thing. It does seem odd that he'd try to get into this fight if he were scum, it seems like town vs. town to me.
Metal Sonic's entry seems odd and fluffy to me, I'm not sure if the "policy lynch" vote on Haruno is a joke or not, but:
if it is a joke; This is day two, I think we're past that phase man.
if it's not; Could you explain why Haruno would be a policy lynch? I'm assuming you're voting based on their meta here?
anyways, I'm reading Metal Sonic as scum for now, can anyone tell me if that's his normal meta?
On #417, same, that may be the shittiest version of that gif I've ever seen [although if we're including individual cases of the same version of the gif, I've seen the same version in a way smaller size, making it worse]
on #427, yeah, I'm gonna have to reiterate my question about why Haruno's a policy lynch, once again I assume it's their meta, I vaguely remember reading comments on their meta earlier in the thread that were disparaging
Metal Sonic gives some reads with nothing to back them up, this seems to be part of his posting style. I don't particularly like it, seems scummy to me. Can anyone comment on if this is part of his meta as well?
I like #440, it's nice to see a big post of reads from Hitmonleet, I don't think(?) we've had one so far. Town leaning.
if everyone just threw around "x is town, y is scum" without any explanations then we may as well be randomly voting, I don't really feel like that's a valid excuse
#471 is interesting, it's NAI, but I like the content
Regarding Earlio's #375, I was confused for a bit too, this has probably been resolved already but it's just weird flavor. Or the role is really basatard and flips as the opposite alignment on death but since he was almost certainly the mafia kill that's impossible, so yeah, flavor text.
I like Texas's #383, it's a lot of logical enough reads, town read.
Jalmont seems to be getting really aggressive towards Texas later on Page 16, although I guess it's understandable since Texas parroted Proph on the "poor town play" thing. It does seem odd that he'd try to get into this fight if he were scum, it seems like town vs. town to me.
Metal Sonic's entry seems odd and fluffy to me, I'm not sure if the "policy lynch" vote on Haruno is a joke or not, but:
if it is a joke; This is day two, I think we're past that phase man.
if it's not; Could you explain why Haruno would be a policy lynch? I'm assuming you're voting based on their meta here?
anyways, I'm reading Metal Sonic as scum for now, can anyone tell me if that's his normal meta?
On #417, same, that may be the shittiest version of that gif I've ever seen [although if we're including individual cases of the same version of the gif, I've seen the same version in a way smaller size, making it worse]
on #427, yeah, I'm gonna have to reiterate my question about why Haruno's a policy lynch, once again I assume it's their meta, I vaguely remember reading comments on their meta earlier in the thread that were disparaging
Metal Sonic gives some reads with nothing to back them up, this seems to be part of his posting style. I don't particularly like it, seems scummy to me. Can anyone comment on if this is part of his meta as well?
I like #440, it's nice to see a big post of reads from Hitmonleet, I don't think(?) we've had one so far. Town leaning.
ok, this reads as really scummy to me, really? Vote: Metal Sonic for the time being
if everyone just threw around "x is town, y is scum" without any explanations then we may as well be randomly voting, I don't really feel like that's a valid excuse
#471 is interesting, it's NAI, but I like the content
I'll post again sometime tonight, have a thing I need to go to soon
Metal Sonic is my least favorite Mafia player and does post usually like this (i.e a lot of reads + a lot of swagger with nothing to really back it up except for logic like "Because the host gave you a mafia PM")
Read on them is null as of now, but possibly a town lean as I haven't really seen Mafia sonic
why wont you trust the inspect ?? is this a bastard game ?
Granny Pie(2): MeowMIXXX, Aura Guardian
MeowMixxx(1): Texas Cloverleaf
Texas Cloverleaf(1): jalmont
Aura Guardian(1): XnadrojX
Hitmonleet(1): Metal Sonic
Former Hope(1): bluedoom
Thetwinmasters(1): Prophylaxis
Metal Sonic(1): BLOODYRAIN10001
Not Voting(10): bluedoom, Champ1604, Earlio, Former Hope, Granny Pie, Haruno, Hitmonleet, ItzViper482, MoodyCloud, Thetwinmasters
Thetwinmasters has subbed in for Tonithetourguide.
Deadline is in 52 hours, 9 minutes
MeowMixxx(1): Texas Cloverleaf
Texas Cloverleaf(1): jalmont
Aura Guardian(1): XnadrojX
Hitmonleet(1): Metal Sonic
Former Hope(1): bluedoom
Thetwinmasters(1): Prophylaxis
Metal Sonic(1): BLOODYRAIN10001
Not Voting(10): bluedoom, Champ1604, Earlio, Former Hope, Granny Pie, Haruno, Hitmonleet, ItzViper482, MoodyCloud, Thetwinmasters
Thetwinmasters has subbed in for Tonithetourguide.
Deadline is in 52 hours, 9 minutes
i played a game with granny pie before on this site recently and she was acting like this, kind of similar, though i might be wrong, im not too confident on that
oh and i forgot to mention she flipped town, so yeah
we did lynch her
we did lynch her
FH's thought processes are awesome. he always explains his stuff in super long posts, unlike me. although usually wrong, but totally awesome dude and i love him
can someone link me all the flips so far
Texas Cloverleaf
Lots of minor stuff. Gut on champ is pro-town. Then goes against Jalmont (this persists to the next day). Is pro-Prophylaxis, but also wants them on wagons for being able to tell better, later. Joins the flashwagon. Megapost after the night ends. Votes MeowMiXXX and figures Granny and myself are scum. Sorta pro-XnadrojX?
Former Hope
Fishing opening, but then lazy re: unvote when he likes the responses, and admits some OMGUS. Votes toni/twin and quickly unvotes based on them not having been on since the game started. Then considers their quick response after to be surprising - toni on mafia discord? TRs me and texas. Anti-MeowMiXXX. ??? on Granny Pie. Would rather mxmts over Granny Pie, and pings texas to avoid the tie. Says prophylaxis should consider him town, which Proph does. Friendly neighbor power? Possible double scum, but unlikely.
Prophylaxis
Biggest change from my last review is, they were a big factor in the flashwagon on mxmts. More scummy now.
_________________________________
Upon considering Haruno->Texas, and Former Hope->Prophylaxis, my doubts about MeowMiXXX and what their vote is:
Unvote, Vote MeowMiXXX
Lots of minor stuff. Gut on champ is pro-town. Then goes against Jalmont (this persists to the next day). Is pro-Prophylaxis, but also wants them on wagons for being able to tell better, later. Joins the flashwagon. Megapost after the night ends. Votes MeowMiXXX and figures Granny and myself are scum. Sorta pro-XnadrojX?
Former Hope
Fishing opening, but then lazy re: unvote when he likes the responses, and admits some OMGUS. Votes toni/twin and quickly unvotes based on them not having been on since the game started. Then considers their quick response after to be surprising - toni on mafia discord? TRs me and texas. Anti-MeowMiXXX. ??? on Granny Pie. Would rather mxmts over Granny Pie, and pings texas to avoid the tie. Says prophylaxis should consider him town, which Proph does. Friendly neighbor power? Possible double scum, but unlikely.
Prophylaxis
Biggest change from my last review is, they were a big factor in the flashwagon on mxmts. More scummy now.
_________________________________
Upon considering Haruno->Texas, and Former Hope->Prophylaxis, my doubts about MeowMiXXX and what their vote is:
Unvote, Vote MeowMiXXX
Unvote Vote thetwinmasters
Texas Cloverleaf why did you change to twin?
Reasons
Aura Guardian said:
I'm not going to let you openly shade me like this.
Run me through your thought process on this, please. You instantly assuming that me flashwagoning mxmts and mxmts having them flip town instantly makes me scum - why?
Thetwinmasters/Earlio/AG?
- Status