i'm just saying but i get the sense that the majority of new users we get into circus aren't from randoms searching up mafia on the internet but from ppl who are already on smogon. i mean i personally found circus only because i was already on smogon for competitive mons. i think that's the same for a lot of ppl here (eg wifier yeti, zorbees, Haruno, ppl from the showdown! mafia room, etc).
i think focusing on users who are already on this site is more important than the off chance that a random person finds us through google search. that's why i'd be more in favor of something simple like Circus Maximus: Forum Games and not worrying about google search.